Niyamath Parveez

Written by Seema Sapra

This Economic Times story reflects Indian industry and policymakers sensitivity on the issue of any protectionist clamp-down on outsourcing. Though I think the Economic Times jumped the gun here a bit. Its too early to be talking about WTO contests especially since the whole story seems to be based upon this sentence in President Obama’s speech to Congress:

We will root out the waste, fraud, and abuse in our Medicare program that doesn’t make our seniors any healthier, and we will restore a sense of fairness and balance to our tax code by finally ending the tax breaks for corporations that ship our jobs overseas.

The news report captioned “India may contest Obama’s move against outsourcing in WTO” seems to be based upon Minister Kamal Nath’s response on being asked whether India would respond to the suggestion in Obama’s speech. This is what Nath is reported to have answered:

We have to ensure what they (US) are doing is WTO compatible when we are talking about trade, movement of goods, movement of people and movement of services," Commerce and Industry Minister Kamal Nath said here.
"Yes, of course," he said when asked if India will take up the issue of outsourcing with the US administration.
…

Nath said, "One has to see how the US companies using India as a base for technological development respond to their own government." Outsourcing of technology development by large companies cannot be switched on and off, he added.

It should be interesting to see what shape the US measure on discouraging outsourcing takes. A PTI story has more:

Nearly 1,000 US firms, which have shipped their jobs overseas are anticipated to be affected with the proposed elimination of tax incentives. The plan mainly refers to one of the provisions in the tax code that allows companies to pay lesser taxes for profits earned from foreign shores.

Here’s another interesting aspect linking the outsourcing issue with H-1B visas. A Computerworld story discusses this:

The U.S. government’s H-1B visa usage data for fiscal 2008 shows that offshore outsourcing firms based in India are employing a growing number of H-1B workers — a hiring trend that is affecting the IT workforces in communities such as Oldsmar, Fla.

Oldsmar is the home of a technology center operated by The Nielsen Co., which measures TV audiences, consumer trends and other metrics for its clients. Nielsen last year began laying off workers at the facility after announcing in October 2007 a 10-year global outsourcing agreement valued at $1.2 billion with Tata Consultancy Services Ltd.

And while Nielsen cut employees, Mumbai, India-based Tata was increasing its hiring of H-1B workers. Tata received approval for a total of 1,539 H-1B visas during the federal fiscal year that ended last September, according to government data released this week. That was nearly double the 797 visas that the outsourcing and IT services vendor received in fiscal 2007